Tuesday, April 15, 2014

Adverse Possession - A Quick Primer on Adversarial Real Estate Law

Angus McThag responded to my post about the Bundy affair, and made a salient point about adverse possession, and wondered how that rule might apply in the case of Bundy vs. the BLM. 

First, to those who don’t know, the rule of adverse possession is an important part of our property law that you should all probably know about.  It basically says that if person A uses or improves person b’s property in some tangible way for a period of 7 years without person b telling him to stop, then that piece of property becomes the legal possession of person a.  The use may be as simple as just walking across a corner of the lot every day, and beating down a trail to do so (you wouldn’t gain possession of the entire lot, just the trail that you used). 

So many people are wondering if Bundy might not have a claim to that BLM land via adverse possession, since his family has used it for 100 plus years now. 

The answer is a very straightforward “NO.” Even Bundy, himself, isn’t trying to argue otherwise, and he’s taking some pretty serious liberties with what laws he thinks apply to him.

Property owners can avoid adverse possession in one of two ways.  They can either grant an easement to the person using their property, or they can evict them. 

Granting an easement is as simple as drafting an agreement that says “I, the property owner, allow you, the property user, to use my property under the following terms and conditions.”  There are many types of easements, but the simple ones that most people are familiar with are things like leases, rental agreements, and access easements.  As I’ve said before, my family is big into wheat farming on the Palouse.  My family allows what are called “custom” farm outfits to farm their land quite regularly, since most of them are getting too old to farm their land themselves.  “Custom” outfits are essentially landless farmers, who just farm other people’s land.  One outfit has farmed family land continuously for 20 years now, but they hold no legal claim to the land at all, because my family has signed a lease agreement with them.  If they farm it for 150 years, we can still kick them off the ground in year 151 if we so choose, per the terms and conditions of the lease agreement.  It is the risk you take in using ground that you don’t own, especially ground off of which you earn your livelihood.  That custom outfit would be in deep doo-doo if my family terminated their lease, but that is the risk they take.  A family can rent a house for 30 years and not own it in year 31, and be evicted without recourse, because the rental agreement stops the clock on adverse possession

But if that same family squatted in that same house for 7 years, and the property owner did nothing about it, they would own that house.  Or, if the rental contract expired, and they continued to live there rent free for 7 years, they would own the house.    

For the 100 plus years that Bundy’s ranch has used BLM land to graze, he’s had an agreement with the BLM to use that land.  He is not a squatter.  The permits he was supposed to be buying were the lease agreements, just like my family ground with the custom outfit, and if the BLM decides not to renew, or to limit, or whatever, he’s got no recourse. 

Essentially, for that reason, his family has no legal claim to that ground based on years of use, via adverse possession.

The next question, then, is what about once Bundy essentially became a squatter in 1993 and stopped paying for his permits?  That’s been more than 7 years, so why doesn’t he own the ground now? 

The answer is twofold.

One, the government first tried to evict him in 1997.  That’s only four years, not 7, and an attempt to evict stops the clock on adverse possession, even if the tenant chooses to defy the eviction order and stay, as Bundy did.  If you give an order to evict, and the tenant won’t leave, and you do nothing for 7 years, then the tenant gets the property, but the BLM didn’t do that.  They’ve been fighting to get Bundy off their land pretty much continuously since 1997.  So check that off as a reason.

Two, even if the government hadn’t tried to evict him, and he’d been using that ground without their permission for 7 years without them doing a damn thing about it, the ground still wouldn’t belong to Bundy because of one key exception to adverse possession:

You cannot take adverse possession of (AKA condemn) public property.

This is actually a common sense exception, when you think about it, because public ground, by definition, generally allows anyone access without having to ask permission.  You don’t have to ask permission to use a park playground, or hike on a forest service trail.  If it were possible for a private citizen to condemn a public property, then all he’d have to do is walk on a BLM trail every day for 7 years, and that land would be his.  All he’d have to do is swing on a park swing every day for 7 years, and the park would be his.  All he’d have to do is graze cattle on the ground under the radar for 7 years, and he’d be able to take possession of land that belongs to the public. 

Get the picture?  That exception to adverse possession exists exactly for situations like this, to keep men from being able to surreptitiously take possession of public ground by grazing his cows there.  It exists because of guys who venture back into the forest and build ramshackle cabins, and if that cabin isn’t torn down in 7 years, he claims that public forest ground as his own. 


It exists because of men like Cliven Bundy.  

45 comments:

  1. Now I am thinking of mowing the lawn next door. The house has been vacant for quite a while and it needs mown. Seven years of mowing nets the adjacent property if they don't tell me to stop? Seems quite a deal!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It does, doesnt it?

      Problem is if all you did was mow the lawn, thats all youd get:

      The lawn.

      The law is strange...

      Delete
    2. Well, then I could tell him to get his dogs off my lawn! The same people own the next house down as well.

      Delete
    3. And you would have more real estate for which you could holler at teenagers to "get off your lawn!" which, as I get older, I find really is quite amusing...

      Delete
  2. Obviously you are a card carrying democrat that wants more govt. You probably drink prince Reid's bathwater too. The problem with your interpretation of adverse possession is you conveniently leave out the hundred years before 1997. His family farmed the land and has an adverse claim due to his ancestory. You and all your snarky socialist buddies I see making remarks about Mr. Bundy are way out of line.He is not a criminal for defending his heritage and way of life. He is more of a man than you'll ever be.You are also a fool if you think the govt wants this land over grazing rights.You are going to look even more stupid than you already do when it all comes out of what this is really about.You are no Perry Mason,not even a Matlock either.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I responded to you in a post above this one.

      Delete
  3. Adverse possession laws vary by state. The seven years You mention is not a federal law. Here in Hawaii adverse possession takes over 20 years. Some states adverse possession takes as few as two years.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I knew that they varied by state, but I did think that the 7 years was pretty much universal, so thanks for the new knowledge.

      I work primarily in three states, all of whom use the 7 year standard, so I guess I wrongly assumed that that standard was universal.

      Learn something new everyday. :)

      Delete
  4. Should there be another persuasive post you can share next time, I’ll be surely waiting for it. Tinley park houses for sale

    ReplyDelete
  5. Thank you for sharing the information.

    I would like to inform that I have recently came across a site called brian hero who is also providing the service in real estate since 1990 and is a licensed real estate broker in the State of Florida.
    Sunny Isles Real Estates By Brian Hero

    ReplyDelete

  6. Hi your way of explanation about property is impressive.Nice Posting.Keep sharing such important links.
    Properties in Hyderabad

    ReplyDelete
  7. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Probably not a good idea to use an easement to avoid adverse possession since it is added to the dead and is difficult to get rid of. Better to "license" the use of the land, which can be revoked at anytime, usually.

    Not a lawyer, so make sure to consult one for legal advice.

    ReplyDelete
  9. then it's a great idea. Here, we will help you to find ideal rental apartments or houses in Monaco according to your requirements. It does not matter whether you want to move permanently or looking for the holidays. management company rental property

    ReplyDelete
  10. Numerous commercial and residential real estate development projects are stuck in a holding pattern as developers find it increasingly difficult to secure financing and investment participation. So how do you "un-stick" a real estate development project in today's economy? Many real estate development projects can benefit from various strategies that can be implemented to convert them into revenue-generating profit centers despite the current economic and financial barriers and challenges that exist today. This article provides 5 practical strategies and examples for "un-sticking" real Apartments for sale Arrayanes development projects that are stuck in a holding pattern due to the lingering effects of the economic downturn of recent years.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Real estate flipping has become the "in" fad of investing recently. But is flipping real estate the best way for new real estate investors to get started? This article discusses why flipping real estate is not best for new real estate investors, and what method is best for new investors who want to minimize their risk and learn the ropes much faster. off plan properties dubai

    ReplyDelete
  12. Real Estate Investing is not about doing flips, No Money Down or even 'buy and hold'. So many people have been LIED to about Real Estate investments, and I, for one, think it's time to 'get real' about your Real Estate Investing. This article describes just what these lies are, where they come from and how you can stop them before they stop you - and your successful real estate investing career! check more about real estate

    ReplyDelete
  13. Practically anyone who wants to make a career in the property industry can choose to go for the training. If one feels that they can carve their niche in the property sector and have what it takes to excel in the profession, a good real estate course will be of crucial importance. check more about real estate

    ReplyDelete
  14. As technology advances and new business models evolve, the real estate industry has begun to transform itself from providing traditional, carefully controlled "agent-centric" transactions to new "consumer-centric" practices. This article examines some of the recent industry trends and how buyers, sellers and investors can expect to benefit. The "Five Ds" that are driving change in real estate are: 1. Disruption 2. Displacement 3. Demanding consumers 4. Downward pressure on commissions 5. Developing alternatives پیش فروش ستین

    ReplyDelete
  15. Real Estate Investing is not about doing flips, No Money Down or even 'buy and hold'. So many people have been LIED to about Real Estate investments, and I, for one, think it's time to 'get real' about your Real Estate Investing. This article describes just what these lies are, where they come from and how you can stop them before they stop you - and your successful real estate investing career! پروژه ستین

    ReplyDelete
  16. Commercial real estate is a great option for investing in real estate.Though many only think in terms of residential real estate, there are big (in fact huge) profits to be made in commercial real estate investing. Apartments, rental units, strip malls, retail space, warehouses even vacant land are all commercial investments with huge profit potential. پیش فروش ستین

    ReplyDelete
  17. Real Estate Investing is not about doing flips, No Money Down or even 'buy and hold'. So many people have been LIED to about Real Estate investments, and I, for one, think it's time to 'get real' about your Real Estate Investing. This article describes just what these lies are, where they come from and how you can stop them before they stop you - and your successful real estate investing career! پیش فروش پروژه ستین

    ReplyDelete
  18. Real Estate Investing is not about doing flips, No Money Down or even 'buy and hold'. So many people have been LIED to about Real Estate investments, and I, for one, think it's time to 'get real' about your Real Estate Investing. This article describes just what these lies are, where they come from and how you can stop them before they stop you - and your successful real estate investing career! فروش پروژه پدافند

    ReplyDelete
  19. Practically anyone who wants to make a career in the property industry can choose to go for the training. If one feels that they can carve their niche in the property sector and have what it takes to excel in the profession, a good real estate course will be of crucial importance. فروش پروژه پدافند

    ReplyDelete
  20. Real Estate Investing is not about doing flips, No Money Down or even 'buy and hold'. So many people have been LIED to about Real Estate investments, and I, for one, think it's time to 'get real' about your Real Estate Investing. This article describes just what these lies are, where they come from and how you can stop them before they stop you - and your successful real estate investing career! فروش پدافند ارتش

    ReplyDelete
  21. Practically anyone who wants to make a career in the property industry can choose to go for the training. If one feels that they can carve their niche in the property sector and have what it takes to excel in the profession, a good real estate course will be of crucial importance. فروش پدافند ارتش

    ReplyDelete
  22. Engulfing the period of stagnation, the evolution of Indian real estate sector has been phenomenal, impelled by, growing economy, conducive demographics and liberalized foreign direct investment regime. However, now this unceasing phenomenon of real estate sector has started to exhibit the signs of contraction. پروژه پدافند ارتش

    ReplyDelete
  23. One creative way to get started investing in real estate is to use a lease option. The biggest advantage of using lease options to invest in real estate is -- control. This method of investing, basically gives the investor the right to possess -- be in control of -- and profit from a property without owning it. پروژه پدافند ارتش

    ReplyDelete
  24. Appreciate it for all your efforts that you have put in this. very interesting info . backlink analysis

    ReplyDelete
  25. I like your website.. great shades & motif. Performed people design and style this fabulous website yourself or even have people rely on someone else to make it work for you personally? Plz interact when I!|m looking to pattern by myself blog site plus would want to find out wherever u received this particular through. thank you sugaring paste

    ReplyDelete
  26. The material and aggregation is excellent and telltale as comfortably. immobilienmakler mülheim an der ruhr

    ReplyDelete
  27. Do you mind generally if I cite a few of your content articles so long as I deliver you acknowledgement as well as sources returning to yuor web blog? My web pages is in the similar specialized niche as your site and my site guests will make use of some of the information and facts your site present at this website. Please let me know if it is okay with you. Take care! Daniel Gordon profile

    ReplyDelete
  28. Thank you for the sensible critique. Me and my neighbor were just preparing to do some research about this. We got a grab a book from our local library but I think I learned more from this post. I’m very glad to see such wonderful info being shared freely out there. Daniel Gordon donates tech to LA community

    ReplyDelete
  29. I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this article. I am hoping the same best work from you in the future as well. In fact your creative writing abilities has inspired me to start my own Blog Engine blog now. Really the blogging is spreading its wings rapidly. Your write up is a fine example of it. immobilienmakler mülheim

    ReplyDelete
  30. First to obtain your Real Estate license you will need to do a 63 hours pre licensing course. Many online educational sites offer this and can be done in the comfort of your home. If you are more of an In class person, your local community college might offer the course. When taken in actual class, the course may take 4 to 6 weeks due to their scheduling. Online classes you can do at your own pace. So if you want, you may do the entire course in one week. پیش فروش پدافند ارتش

    ReplyDelete
  31. Real estate flipping has become the "in" fad of investing recently. But is flipping real estate the best way for new real estate investors to get started? This article discusses why flipping real estate is not best for new real estate investors, and what method is best for new investors who want to minimize their risk and learn the ropes much faster. پیش فروش پدافند

    ReplyDelete
  32. i would love to use hydrogen fuel on my car, this fuel is really nonpolluting but is not yet very available” more

    ReplyDelete
  33. I often tell people that becoming a millionaire in the real estate business is an easy thing to accomplish. They usually give me a look of bewilderment. I say that you don't have to understand every aspect of real estate in order to begin investing. nevada mortgage companies

    ReplyDelete
  34. Finding the right real estate investment coach and the right buying leads for real estate agents investment education can be painstaking. Knowing what you want and what to look for would definitely help to make things clearer. Where do you start? How do you start? Always start with you!

    ReplyDelete
  35. Comfort is key when outfitting your bedroom with new furniture. Many people tend to focus all of their efforts on their rooms' style. While visual appeal is certainly important, comfort is paramount. Best beds

    ReplyDelete
  36. Pretty nice post. I just stumbled upon your weblog and wanted to say that I have really enjoyed browsing your blog posts. After all I’ll be subscribing to your feed and I hope you write again very soon! profile picture for netflix

    ReplyDelete
  37. The media is currently full of real estate 'doom and gloom' - real estate repossessions and arrears are up and real estate prices are down ... its almost as if the 'sky is about to fall'! This situation has seen many real estate developers, and property investors generally, leave the market - and for those thinking of starting out in real estate development, these are scary times indeed. what is asset progression

    ReplyDelete
  38. The media is currently full of real estate 'doom and gloom' - real estate repossessions and arrears are up and real estate prices are down ... its almost as if the 'sky is about to fall'! This situation has seen many real estate developers, and property investors generally, leave the market - and for those thinking of starting out in real estate development, these are scary times indeed. Duncan Realtors

    ReplyDelete
  39. Introduction This article has been written to provide a novice person considering real estate investing some fundamental concepts to consider as you commit yourself to this area of interest. Like all new endeavors explored, it will be to your advantage to have some basic knowledge on the particular topic before you can truly appreciate if this is right for you. What Are The Financial Benefits Of Investing In Real Estate? Realtors in spartanburg

    ReplyDelete
  40. Real Estate Investing is not about doing flips, No Money Down or even 'buy and hold'. So many people have been LIED to about Real Estate investments, and I, for one, think it's time to 'get real' about your Real Estate Investing. This article describes just what these lies are, where they come from and how you can stop them before they stop you - and your successful real estate investing career! Paylessforwindows.com

    ReplyDelete